Best Sellers

Best-Selling Diamond Jewelry - Nolita Diamonds’ Most-Loved Designs

Welcome to Nolita Diamonds’ Best Sellers Collection, where timeless craftsmanship meets modern New York style. This curated selection showcases our most popular diamond jewelry pieces, loved by customers for their exceptional quality, versatile style, and attainable luxury. Whether you’re looking for 14K gold diamond studs, a lab-grown diamond necklace, or a statement paperclip chain, you’ll find the pieces everyone’s talking about right here.

Why These Pieces Are Our Best Sellers

Our best-selling jewelry is more than just beautiful, it’s chosen again and again for a reason:

• Proven customer favorites – Designs that consistently earn five-star reviews and become daily go-to accessories.
• Accessible luxury – Fine jewelry made with solid 14K gold, natural diamonds, and lab-grown diamonds, starting under $100.
• Effortless versatility – Styles that look stunning on their own or layered for a personalized statement.

Featured Favorites in Our Best Sellers

Classic Diamond Stud Earrings

Our 14K Gold Diamond Studs (from $95) are the ultimate everyday essential. Available in natural or lab-grown diamonds, they offer timeless sparkle that works with any outfit.

Diamond Initial Earrings & Charms

Personalized jewelry is always in style. Our Diamond Initial Stud Earrings (from $195) combine meaningful design with refined sparkle.

Diamond Lightning Bolt Earrings

A customer favorite for adding edge to any look, these 14K diamond lightning bolt studs (from $175) bring bold, playful energy to your jewelry collection.

Diamond Huggie Hoop Earrings

Our classic huggies (from $155) are perfect for stacking or wearing solo. Comfortable, chic, and endlessly wearable.

Paperclip Chain Necklaces & Diamond Charms

The Baby Paperclip Chain Necklace (from $525) pairs perfectly with our Diamond Dog Tag Pendant (from $515) for a modern, layered look.

Bead Candy Diamond Spacer Bead

From our Bead Candy series, the Diamond Cascade Spacer Bead ($995) is perfect for adding a touch of luxury to bracelets or necklaces.

What Makes Nolita Diamonds’ Best Sellers Stand Out

• Crafted in premium materials – Solid 14K gold for lasting beauty, paired with ethically sourced natural or lab-grown diamonds.
• Signature New York minimalism – Clean lines, refined silhouettes, and a downtown-cool vibe that transitions effortlessly from day to night.
• Gift-ready presentation – Every piece arrives in elegant packaging, ready to delight someone special, or yourself.

Perfect For Every Occasion

Our best-selling jewelry is designed for birthdays, anniversaries, graduations, bridal parties, or simply as a self-care splurge. With price points ranging from under $100 to $1,000+, there’s a piece to fit every budget and style preference.

Shop Nolita Diamonds’ Best Sellers today to discover why these pieces have captured the hearts of our customers. Elevate your everyday look or find the perfect gift that will be cherished for years.

Frequently Asked Questions - Nolita Diamonds Best Sellers

What makes Nolita Diamonds’ Best Sellers so popular?

Our Best Sellers are customer favorites because they combine timeless design, premium 14K gold, and ethically sourced natural or lab-grown diamonds at accessible price points. Each piece is reviewed, loved, and often purchased again by returning customers.

Are lab-grown diamonds real diamonds?

Yes! Lab-grown diamonds have the same chemical composition, brilliance, and durability as mined diamonds. The only difference is their origin—lab-grown diamonds are created in controlled environments, making them an eco-friendly and sustainable choice.

Can I wear my Nolita Diamonds jewelry every day?

Absolutely. Our 14K gold and diamond jewelry is designed for daily wear. To keep your pieces looking their best, we recommend gentle cleaning with a soft cloth and avoiding harsh chemicals or abrasive surfaces.

Do you offer different diamond sizes for earrings?

Yes. Many of our best-selling diamond stud earrings and huggie hoops come in multiple carat sizes, allowing you to choose the perfect level of sparkle for your style and budget.

Are these pieces good for gifting?

Definitely. All Nolita Diamonds jewelry comes in elegant, gift-ready packaging. Our Best Sellers, like the Diamond Initial Stud Earrings or Paperclip Chain Necklace, make timeless gifts for birthdays, anniversaries, graduations, or holidays.

How do I choose between natural and lab-grown diamonds?

It comes down to preference and budget. Natural diamonds have a traditional appeal, while lab-grown diamonds offer the same beauty at a more affordable price, with added sustainability benefits.

Do you offer free shipping or returns?

Yes. We offer free U.S. shipping on most orders and accept returns within our stated policy window. Please see our Shipping & Returns page for details.

Can I layer Best Sellers with other Nolita Diamonds pieces?

Absolutely. Our jewelry is designed for mixing, matching, and layering, for example, pair the Diamond Huggies & Hoops with the Paperclip Chain Necklace and a Bead Candy charm for a chic, personalized look.